Freedom for Whom? Slavery, The Declaration of Independence, and the Incomplete Promise of July Fourth

This in-depth article examines the profound contradiction at the heart of American independence: the celebration of liberty on July 4th, 1776, while millions of Black people remained enslaved. It explores how the Declaration of Independence, authored by slaveholders, proclaimed freedom while denying it to many. The piece reveals how slavery shaped America’s economy, laws, and national identity, and how its legacy continues to affect Black Americans today. Through historical analysis and powerful voices like Frederick Douglass, the article challenges readers to confront the truth, honor the excluded, and push for a fuller, more honest vision of American freedom.

GRIM REALITYSINS OF THE FLESHABYASS

7/4/20255 min read

Historical Context: The Birth of a Nation

On July 4, 1776, a group of colonial revolutionaries, frustrated by the tyranny of British rule, signed a document that would alter the course of world history. The Declaration of Independence declared boldly and unambiguously: “All men are created equal.” It claimed all had the right to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” These words would echo through centuries, a rallying cry for freedom and equality.

Yet, in that moment of proclaimed liberty, nearly one-fifth of the population of the American colonies—over 500,000 people—remained in chains. They were enslaved Africans and their descendants, bought, sold, and bred like livestock. The men who signed the Declaration, including its chief author Thomas Jefferson, owned human beings. Their freedom was built upon the bondage of others.

The Founding Paradox: Liberty and Slavery

Thomas Jefferson penned the Declaration’s most iconic words, yet he enslaved over 600 people in his lifetime. George Washington owned more than 300. James Madison, James Monroe, and even Benjamin Franklin (who later became an abolitionist) all participated in or benefited from slavery. Eleven of the first sixteen U.S. presidents were slaveholders.

Originally, Jefferson included a paragraph in the Declaration condemning King George III for perpetuating the transatlantic slave trade. Southern delegates, however, demanded its removal. The final draft omitted any mention of slavery—conveniently sanitizing the truth to maintain unity among the colonies.

It is a moral contradiction that cannot be overstated: the nation’s founding document asserted universal equality, while deliberately excluding Black people from that promise.

In 1776, slavery was legal in all thirteen colonies. It was not a Southern issue—it was an American institution. Northern ports profited from the slave trade, while Southern plantations grew rich on enslaved labor. Cotton, rice, tobacco, sugar—these commodities formed the bedrock of the American economy, extracted through unimaginable cruelty.

Black Lives in the Shadows of Independence

For enslaved people, Independence Day meant nothing. The words "freedom" and "liberty" were spoken by the very mouths that denied them humanity. On July 4th, there were no celebrations for Black Americans—only the continuation of forced labor, whippings, rape, family separations, and lifelong captivity.

African Americans were denied citizenship, denied literacy, denied marriage, denied inheritance, and denied personhood. They were not seen as men or women but as tools—living instruments of profit.

And yet, Black resistance never ceased. From slave revolts to secret literacy schools, from running north through the Underground Railroad to preserving spiritual songs coded with maps and messages of escape, enslaved people rejected the moral framework imposed upon them. They claimed their humanity in silence and in rebellion.

Frederick Douglass and the Mirror of Truth

In 1852, nearly a century after the Declaration’s signing, abolitionist and formerly enslaved man Frederick Douglass was invited to deliver a speech in Rochester, New York, commemorating the Fourth of July. What followed was one of the most powerful indictments of American hypocrisy ever written.

“What, to the American slave, is your Fourth of July? I answer: a day that reveals to him, more than all other days in the year, the gross injustice and cruelty to which he is the constant victim...”

Douglass did not deny the brilliance of the Constitution or the value of the Declaration’s ideals. But he called out the profound disconnect between principle and practice—a disconnect that persists today. His words remain a haunting echo of a wound never fully healed.

The Economic Foundation of Slavery

Slavery was not just a moral failure—it was an engine of economic power. By the time of the American Revolution, the economy of the colonies—both North and South—was deeply intertwined with slavery. In the South, massive plantations grew cash crops like cotton and tobacco, which were exported to Europe in exchange for weapons, manufactured goods, and more enslaved people.

In the North, shipping magnates, banks, insurance companies, and factories all profited from the trade in human beings or the raw materials their labor produced. Brown University, Aetna, J.P. Morgan, and many other prominent institutions have since revealed their historical ties to slavery.

The economy of the newly formed United States was not merely supported by slavery—it was built upon it.

Law and Power: Codifying Racial Injustice

Slavery was protected and preserved by law. The U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1789, contains multiple clauses designed to appease slaveholding states. The Three-Fifths Compromise allowed states to count three-fifths of their enslaved populations for purposes of representation, giving white enslavers disproportionate power in Congress. The Fugitive Slave Clause required that runaway enslaved people be returned to their owners, even from free states.

These laws entrenched slavery within the very framework of American governance. And they laid the foundation for generations of racial injustice. The legal system that once upheld slavery later upheld segregation, disenfranchisement, and mass incarceration.

Justice in America has often served the powerful at the expense of the oppressed.

"Interview with Ex-Slave Aunt Harriet Smith – Part 1" is a rare and powerful historical recording capturing the voice of Aunt Harriet Smith, a formerly enslaved African-American woman. Likely recorded during the 1930s as part of the Federal Writers' Project, this audio offers a firsthand account of life under slavery in the American South.

Please note: the audio quality is aged and may be difficult to understand at times due to the recording technology of the era. However, we strongly encourage viewers to listen closely, reflect deeply, and we encourage doing your own research into the lives of those who lived through slavery.

Harriet’s testimony is a raw, emotional window into a past that should never be forgotten. Her story — and the silence of countless others — speaks volumes about America’s complex and painful legacy. Let her voice be heard, respected, and remembered.

From Abolition to Segregation: The War Never Ended

Slavery was abolished in 1865 with the 13th Amendment, but its legacy lived on. During Reconstruction, newly freed Black Americans briefly participated in democratic life, electing officials, starting businesses, and building communities. But by the 1870s, white supremacist backlash violently rolled back these gains.

The rise of Jim Crow laws, lynchings, and systemic racism ensured that Black Americans would remain second-class citizens for another century. Schools were segregated, voting was suppressed through poll taxes and literacy tests, and violence was a constant threat.

Even after the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s, structural inequality persisted. Today, racial disparities in wealth, education, housing, healthcare, and incarceration are direct consequences of the centuries-old system of racial slavery and its aftermath.

Final Thoughts: Truth, Justice, and Historical Clarity

The story of the Fourth of July cannot be complete without the truth of who was left out. The Declaration of Independence was a document of promise, but for millions of Black Americans, that promise was never delivered.

To truly honor the ideals of America, we must confront the contradictions at its core. The Founding Fathers spoke of liberty while maintaining bondage. They declared all men equal while denying humanity to those they enslaved. The wealth of the early republic was stained with the suffering of stolen lives.

Yet from this darkness, Black Americans carved out resilience, culture, and power. From Douglass to Tubman, from Du Bois to King, from protests to poetry, they transformed the American narrative—fighting not to destroy its ideals but to finally make them real.

Recognizing the full truth of our founding is not an act of division—it is an act of justice. Only through reckoning can there be reconciliation. And only through truth can there be real freedom.

Sources

Keywords

Fourth of July slavery, Black Americans and Independence Day, Declaration of Independence racism, Thomas Jefferson slaveholder, Frederick Douglass July 4th speech, American hypocrisy slavery, Jim Crow legacy, Juneteenth vs Fourth of July, founding fathers slavery, systemic racism in US history, incomplete American freedom, Black history and July 4th, reclaiming Independence Day, justice and American identity, Black patriotism